Résumé
A comparison was made between the errors for the simulated and test performance of a scroll compressor based on three generalised modelling approaches. Four types of refrigerants, namely R22, R134a, R407C and R410A, were analysed, each using a number of compressors which cover the low to medium capacity range. It was found that the use of the constant-polytropic-coefficient approach (CPC) yielded much higher errors in the simulated isentropic efficiencies than those based on the constant-polytropic-efficiency approach (CPE) and the Mallen–Saville approach (MS). The CPE was the best among the three approaches considered, although it was computationally the least efficient. The average errors in the simulated isentropic efficiencies ranged from 8.3 to 10.1% for the four types of refrigerants considered while the corresponding errors in the simulated refrigerant mass flow rates and compressor power inputs varied from 1.1 to 1.8% and 7.7 to 10%. Meanwhile, the simplest CPC should be dismissed on account of the large resultant error and the yielding of incorrect trends in the simulated isentropic efficiencies.
Documents disponibles
Format PDF
Pages : 1369-1375
Disponible
Prix public
20 €
Prix membre*
Gratuit
* meilleur tarif applicable selon le type d'adhésion (voir le détail des avantages des adhésions individuelles et collectives)
Détails
- Titre original : A comparison of different generalised modelling approaches for a scroll refrigerant compressor.
- Identifiant de la fiche : 30008124
- Langues : Anglais
- Source : International Journal of Refrigeration - Revue Internationale du Froid - vol. 36 - n. 4
- Date d'édition : 06/2013
Liens
Voir d'autres articles du même numéro (21)
Voir la source
Indexation
-
Thèmes :
HCFC;
Compresseurs;
HFC - Mots-clés : R410A; R407C; R134a; Comparaison; R22; Modélisation; Frigorigène; Compresseur à spirale
-
Modelling of reciprocating and scroll compressors.
- Auteurs : DUPREZ M. E., DUMONT E., FRERE M.
- Date : 08/2007
- Langues : Anglais
- Source : International Journal of Refrigeration - Revue Internationale du Froid - vol. 30 - n. 5
- Formats : PDF
Voir la fiche
-
Comparison of compressor efficiency between rot...
- Auteurs : KATO T., SHIRAFUJI Y., KAWAGUCHI S.
- Date : 23/07/1996
- Langues : Anglais
- Source : Proceedings of the 1996 International Compressor Engineering Conference at Purdue.
Voir la fiche
-
Presente y futuro de los refrigerantes: sustitu...
- Date : 03/2001
- Langues : Espagnol
- Source : Refrig. Frial - n. 58
Voir la fiche
-
Le CO2 comme frigorigène : comparaisons avec d'...
- Auteurs : DOMBLIDES J. P., DUMINIL M., VRINAT G.
- Date : 05/2002
- Langues : Français
- Source : Rev. gén. Froid - vol. 91 - n. 1023
Voir la fiche
-
Effects of new refrigerants on compressor effic...
- Auteurs : DAVEY J. P.
- Date : 20/11/1997
- Langues : Anglais
- Source : Reducing refrigeration running costs: practical and cost effective solutions.
Voir la fiche