IIR document
Refrigerant Selection – Comparing Apples With Oranges?
Number: 0144
Author(s) : CLELAND D.
Summary
Refrigerant selection is often a difficult decision given the combined constraints of safety, environmental impact, energy efficiency and cost. There is no perfect refrigerant so refrigerant choice is usually a qualitative trade-off between quite different metrics. Once safety and direct environmental impacts are taken into account, energy efficiency is often a key criterion. Guidelines for comparing refrigerant energy efficiency to enable informed refrigerant selection are defined. If these guidelines are not followed, there is a risk that the comparison will be invalid and potentially misleading. Most cycle analyses ignore important aspects such as the effect of lubricants, and of refrigerant thermophysical properties on pressure drops, heat transfer coefficients and other factors affecting system performance. Comparison of proposed commercial systems are often unfair because the systems frequently have different cycle designs, levels of investment, quality of components, and/or other aspects of the basis of comparison are different (e.g. for summer design conditions rather than on an annual basis). Often the benefits of natural refrigerants are not fully apparent if simplistic comparison methods are used. Comparisons of refrigerants should use a system rather than a cycle analysis and should clearly state the basis of the comparison and any assumptions made, so the relevance to other scenarios can be easily assessed.
Available documents
Format PDF
Pages: 20 p.
Available
Public price
20 €
Member price*
15 €
* Best rate depending on membership category (see the detailed benefits of individual and corporate memberships).
Details
- Original title: Refrigerant Selection – Comparing Apples With Oranges?
- Record ID : 30035393
- Languages: English
- Subject: Technology
- Source: 17th IIR-Gustav Lorentzen Conference on Natural Refrigerants. Proceedings. Hamilton, New Zealand, August 23-26 2026.
- Publication date: 2026/08
- DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.18462/iir.gl2026.0144
Links
See other articles from the proceedings (91)
See the conference proceedings
Indexing
- Themes: N/A
- Keywords: N/A